Product Review: L'Oreal Lineur Intense Brush Tip Eyeliner

Product Description:
Stand out with a dramatically bold or sleek look. Lineur Intense Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner has a tapered natural brush that gives you the control to create the most precise lines for your desired eye looks.

All-day wear up to eight hours.
Water-resistant.
Smudge-proof.
Fragrance-free.
Ophthalmologist-tested.
Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

My Review:
Eyeliner is probably one of my favourite makeup products. I can never skip eyeliner no matter what. I always adored the look of liquid liner. The dramatic look that it can create. I do prefer using pencil eyeliners much more than liquid liners though, so I haven't tried very many liquid liners. But I recently decided to give this a try. The brush tip definitely doesn't look as refined as it does in the picture on the one I got. I don't know if they're all like that, or if I just got a bad one? But mine is like this:

Which is very unappealing to me. Upon opening the first time and wanting to try it, after I saw it I didn't even want to try it until another day when I wouldn't be going out, because I just knew I'd mess up with a tip like that.
So then I finally had a day where I wouldn't be going out and I just decided to test this out. The first thing I noticed, was that the wand is very long. I wasn't used to it. It didn't give me as much control as I would've liked. So then onto the application. It didn't turn out that bad. It looked perfect actually. Though it was slightly harder to make thin, tapered lines because of the shape of the brush. And required going over a few times for the thinner lines since they'd come out somewhat.... wispy, I might say, as you can see in the following photo of just some random lines I drew on my hand with the eyeliner.

Now for the formula itself, it did last the entire day without smudging one bit. Even when I try to rub it off with my finger, it doesn't budge a bit. It is waterproof to an extent. With the lines I drew on my hand, I ran it under the tap and it stayed for a while, and then the thicker lines just peeled off itself and gradually the thinner ones. And with a touch, the rest of it came off. I am really satisfied with this eyeliner overall. I just wish that it came with a better brush tip. Perhaps next time I will try the felt tip instead.